Hi! I went with the XS waterproof midi, which has worked really well for me for the past couple years, especially in rain and snow. I haven’t felt the need to get a longer puffer.

Glad it’s helpful! I remember when I was going to buy my first one I wanted a lot of reviews since it’s a big purchase. My latest obsession is now the Sweatfleece, so I’ll put a post up for that before next fall.